Get the Top Property Dispute Lawyer - GIBB Law, Kaysville
Property Disputes Dustin Gibb February 2, 2024

Property Dispute Lawyer in Kaysville and Clearfield

A new survey shows the fence is three feet off. The neighbor blocks the only road to your back lot. A tenant stops paying, or a landlord keeps your deposit. Property disputes get personal quickly, because they involve the place you live or the property you depend on. Dustin Gibb helps you understand your rights and resolve the dispute in a way that makes sense.

Gibb Law Firm handles property disputes in Utah, including boundaries and fences, easements and access, landlord-tenant issues, HOA disputes, construction defects, neighbor nuisances, and property damage. Dustin represents both sides: owners and neighbors, landlords and tenants. Utah has specific rules on boundaries and adverse possession that often decide these cases.

Property disputes we handle

  • Boundaries and fences

    The fence, driveway, or shed isn’t where the deed says the line is

  • Easements and access

    Shared driveways, blocked roads, utility access, and disputed rights of way

  • Quiet title

    Clearing up competing claims to ownership

  • Landlord-tenant

    Evictions, unpaid rent, deposits, repairs, and lease disputes, for both sides

  • HOA disputes

    Rules, fines, assessments, and disputes between owners and associations

  • Construction defects

    Roofs, foundations, and other work that wasn’t done right

  • Neighbor nuisance

    Ongoing interference with the use of your property

  • Property damage

    Damage caused by someone’s negligence or intentional acts

How Utah decides where a boundary really is

Most people assume the deed decides it. Usually it does, but not always.

Deed and survey

The deed and a survey are the starting point. A current survey by a licensed surveyor is often the first thing we recommend.

Boundary by acquiescence

If neighbors have treated a fence or other visible line as the boundary for many years without objecting, Utah courts may treat that line as the legal boundary, even if the deed says otherwise.

Adverse possession

Someone can claim land they’ve occupied, but Utah sets a high bar: continuous occupation and a claim for seven years, plus payment of all property taxes on that land during that time. The tax requirement defeats many adverse possession claims, because people rarely pay taxes on land outside their deeded parcel. Public land set aside for public use can’t be taken this way.

What this means for you: if a survey shows a fence is off, don’t tear it down or move it on your own. How long it’s been there, and how both owners have treated it, may matter more than the survey.

Landlord-tenant disputes, on both sides

Utah evictions move fast.

If you’re a landlord

  • For unpaid rent, the process starts with a 3-business-day notice to pay or vacate.
  • The notice has to be correct. A defective notice can delay everything.
  • A tenant who stays unlawfully can owe rent, fees, costs, and treble (triple) damages.

If you’re a tenant

  • After being served with an eviction lawsuit, you usually have only 3 business days to file an answer.
  • Missing that deadline can mean a default judgment, and possibly treble damages.
  • Deposit disputes, repair problems, and improper notices are all worth raising early.

When the dispute is with a neighbor

You’ll likely keep living next to this person after the dispute ends. That’s why we often start with a clear letter, a survey, or mediation rather than a lawsuit. When a neighbor won’t engage, or the problem keeps getting worse, a court action to establish the boundary, protect an easement, or stop a nuisance may be the right step.

Property experience

  • Dustin earned a Utah real estate license in 2016, so he understands transactions and property records from the inside, not just from litigation.
  • Ironwood HOA, Inc. v. New Star GC, Bartile Roofs, Inc.: dismissal on summary judgment.
  • Several of Dustin’s Avvo client reviews come from real estate and landlord-tenant matters.

Past results don’t guarantee a similar outcome.

Property dispute mistakes

Moving or tearing down the fence yourself

Self-help can create liability and weaken your position.

Locking out a tenant or removing their belongings

Landlords need a court order first.

Ignoring an eviction summons

Three business days go by very quickly.

Relying on an old survey or a verbal agreement with the previous owner

Get it confirmed in writing.

Property dispute questions

Not safely. If the fence has stood for a long time, it may affect where the legal boundary is. Get advice first.

Only in narrow circumstances. Utah requires seven years of continuous possession plus payment of the property taxes.

Among the fastest in the country. Notices run in business days, and tenants often have only 3 business days to answer.

Sometimes. The governing documents (CC&Rs, bylaws, and rules) usually decide what’s possible, so we start there.

Gibb Law Property Disputes Update

Utah Boundary Ruling Puts Original Survey Markers in Focus

On October 22, 2026, the Utah Court of Appeals issued its published decision in Boyer v. Rubin, 2026 UT App 160. The dispute involved a wedge of land between neighboring homes. Applying established Utah boundary law, the court held that, for neighboring owners whose shared boundary is defined by one plat, monuments placed by the original surveyor before any lot sales control conflicting descriptions on that plat. The court rejected limiting that rule to government surveyors and directed the trial court to quiet title to the disputed land in the Boyers.

The decision is not a new statute, and it does not mean every stake or fence determines a property line. If survey measurements, deeds, or plat descriptions appear to conflict, gather existing surveys, plats, deeds, and photographs for coordinated surveying and legal review before escalating a disagreement. The history and placement of original survey markers may matter; the ruling does not decide how another property dispute will end.

General information, not legal advice.

Discuss a boundary disagreement with us
Source: Boyer v. Rubin, published October 22, 2026.

What to bring to your consultation

✓Your deed, title policy, and any surveys
✓Photos of the fence, structure, or damage, with dates if possible
✓The lease, notices, and payment records for landlord-tenant disputes
✓HOA governing documents and letters for HOA disputes
✓Contractor agreements and invoices for construction problems
✓Letters or messages with the other party

Talk with Dustin about your property dispute

Free consultation · Kaysville, Clearfield (by appointment), or virtual · (801) 725-6035

Schedule a Consultation

Fill out the form and we'll be in touch soon!

How we can help you?